This is a story about a multi-million dollar cookbook by a social media influencer, published by a blue-chip publisher, featuring numerous recipes that, in my opinion, are plagiarised, given the detailed and extensive word-for-word similarities to mine and those of other authors.
**UPDATE: I’ve had to turn off further comments because there is additional risk of legal action being brought against me by Penguin and Brooki by what you say. But thank you, for the support you have shown. I was so nervous and worried.**
penguin LEGAL DISPUTE summary
I have made copyright infringement allegations against Penguin Random House Australia, claiming there are plagiarised recipes in the bestselling book Bake with Brooki, including two from my website and other authors, including cookbooks.
To me, the similarities between the recipes in question are far too specific and detailed to be dismissed as coincidence.
Penguin has denied the allegations. I have received no response from Brooke Bellamy, the author.
I’m speaking up because staying silent protects this kind of behaviour. Profiting from plagiarised recipes is unethical – even if it is not copyright infringement – and undermines the integrity of the entire book.
And it’s a slap in the face to every author who puts in the hard work to create original content rather than cutting corners.
Personal note: This isn’t a post I’m publishing lightly. I’ve spent many sleepless nights fretting over it, and many hours writing it. The easiest and safest path would be to stay silent. I know there’s risk that legal action may be brought against me for speaking out, and it’s daunting to take on a major publisher and an influencer with a huge TikTok following.
But I’m going ahead because, in my heart, I know it’s the right thing to do. If my words feel a little clunky, forgive me, it’s because of legal constraints. ~ Nagi
It all began with a reader email
In November 2024, a reader emailed to say that she noticed “remarkable similarities” between my Caramel Slice recipe and the version in the newly released Bake With Brooki, a cookbook by Brooke Bellamy, an Australian social media influencer with almost 4 million followers who has a cookie shop in Queensland.
This email went on to say that “even to my novice eye, I noticed that her recipe seemed to replicate Nagi’s almost exactly albeit a few changes in wording”.
Bake with Brooki was published in October 2024 by Penguin Random House, one of the largest publishers in Australia.
I’m no stranger to seeing my recipes being copied online. But seeing what appeared to me to be one of my recipes printed in a book launched with a huge publicity campaign from one of Australia’s biggest publishers was shocking – it has sold over $4.6 million worth of sales in under six months (92,849 copies sold as of 23 April 2025, according to Nielsen BookScan, RRP $49.99).
The first recipe – Caramel slice comparison
Here’s a comparison of extracts of the Caramel Slice recipe on my website published in 2020 with the version in Bake with Brooki (2024). Click here for a photo of the page from Bake With Brooki to compare the recipes as a whole.
While recipes can resemble one another, because there are only so many ways some recipes can be made, the precision and detail in the similarities in this case are, in my opinion, far too strong to be a co-incidence.
My Caramel Slice recipe is special because it is made using caramel as the base (I mean, the name..!) rather than golden syrup which is the typical recipe (gives it a metallic flavour, I swear!). I can tell you the exact moment in my life that triggered the creation of this recipe – how and why it came to be, and what I tried before deciding that I had figured out The One.
Lawyers and letters
I wrote to Penguin immediately, with my first letter sent on 4 December 2024. Disappointingly, instead of engaging in civil discussions with me, Penguin brought in lawyers and resorted to what felt to me legal intimidation – letters in stern, aggressive tones packed with pages of legal jargon that I struggled to make sense of.
I engaged my own lawyers to represent me – Simpsons, a law firm specialising in intellectual property, to help me understand my rights, assess my legal position, and handle correspondence from Penguin’s lawyers. This is my lawyer, Adam Simpson, a partner at the firm:
More plagiarised recipes surfaced
In the months we’ve been going back and forth with Penguin’s lawyers, more recipes that looks to me to have been plagiarised have surfaced, including another recipe from my website (Baklava) and recipes from other authors.
I invite you to form your own opinion by reviewing the side by side comparisons of extracts I’ve provided of my recipes – Caramel Slice (above), and Baklava (below), as well as comparing those recipes as a whole.
One particular recipe by a very well known, beloved cookbook author bears similarities so detailed, extensive, and specific that, in my view, dismissing it as a coincidence would be absurd. Due to legal constraints, and out of respect for and at the request of the publisher, I am unable to share further details at this time.
Similarly, for other authors I’ve been in contact with, out of respect for and at the request of them, I cannot share further details at this time.
Recipe 2: Baklava
Baklava is a recipe I published in 2018 that I sourced from and credited to Natasha’s Kitchen. I completely rewrote the recipe in my own words after testing it quite extensively, the way I make it, with my tips to make it foolproof. Click here for a comparison so you can see the writing difference.
And here is a side-by-side look at extracts of the Baklava recipe I published to the one featured in Bake with Brooki. Click here for a photo from the book to compare the recipes as a whole. To me, the similarities speak for themselves.
Feels like exploitation
I put a huge amount of time and effort into testing recipes, whether it’s an original creation or one adapted from another source. It is what I am known for – the press have called me “obsessive” about testing on more than one occasion.
And I share them freely on my website for anyone to enjoy.
To see them plagiarised (in my view) and used in a book for profit, without permission, and without credit, doesn’t just feel unfair. It feels like a blatant exploitation of my work.
And because the income from my website helps fund my food bank, RecipeTin Meals, this isn’t just legally questionable – I find it ethically indefensible.
Plagiarism is not excusable
In my opinion, plagiarism is never excusable, no matter how small. Every recipe represents hours of work. Taking even one recipe without credit is a breach of trust that undermines the integrity of the entire book. I have not examined the book thoroughly. I do not have the means or skills to do so. how many more would I find if I did?
Regardless, it’s not about the number – it’s about the principle. Rewarding shortcuts devalues the hard work of every original creator who does things the right way.
And let’s not forget – this is not a small book gathering dust in the dark corner of bookshops. This has been a blockbuster launched with a big marketing campaign. $4.6 million worth of sales in Australia alone, in less than 6 months. Both the author and publisher made a huge splash about it on launch.
Why I am speaking up
I’m speaking up today because staying silent only protects their behaviour which, even if not a technical breach of copyright, I think is unacceptable and unethical.
And to me, this isn’t just about plagiarism. I’ve written two cookbooks. I know what it takes. Every sentence, every photo, every recipe, the sleepless nights, putting your heart and soul into every page.
So when someone comes along and puts out a book, cutting corners?
That’s not just disrespectful. It’s a kick in the guts of every author who actually puts in the hard yards to create original work.
I think it’s disgraceful that a blue chip publisher like Penguin continued selling the book after I brought this to their attention way back on 4 December 2024.
Plagiarism and the responsibility of publishers
Book publishers absolutely should check for plagiarism. It’s a basic part of protecting the integrity of the publishing industry and the rights of original creators.
My publisher, Pan Macmillan, ran my cookbooks through plagiarism detection software without me even knowing about it! For any reputable publisher, I would think that using plagiarism software would be a basic step in quality control.
In addition, I would expect that publishers employ editors experienced and skilled enough to spot when writing doesn’t match an author’s voice, there are gaps in a story, or when recipe blurbs don’t quite add up. It’s not hard to spot when something doesn’t look right – if you’re actually looking.
What I asked for: accountability
I asked Penguin to withdraw the book containing the plagiarised recipes from sale, either attribute or remove my recipes from future reprints of the book, and to make a substantial donation to a charity in lieu of financial compensation. Not for RecipeTin Meals – I don’t want their money. I did not even ask for reimbursement of legal fees I have incurred, which has now run into the tens of thousands.
I also personally wrote a letter to Penguin’s directors and sent two letters to Brooke Bellamy. I didn’t receive a response to any of them.
Allegations denied. What happens now?
Penguin have denied my allegations, stating in a letter from their lawyers that “Our client respectfully rejects your clients’ allegations and confirms that the recipes in the BWB Book were written by Brooke Bellamy.”
I ceased further correspondence with Penguin via their lawyers last month as there was no point continuing. They would not admit wrong doing and would not agree to take steps to remedy the situation to my satisfaction. How I wish I could tell you what they offered to do – but I can’t.
In recent weeks, I understand that a new edition of the book has been quietly released into the market which has a different Caramel Slice recipe (typical golden syrup version). Eventually, this will replace stock in all retailers, though I’m sure the original version remains.
The other recipes that have been plagiarised, in my view, that I brought to Penguin’s attention at a later date have not (yet) been changed.
But, more than anything, I am just disappointed
If there’s one word that summarises how I feel about this whole situation, it’s not anger or resentment or bitterness.
It’s disappointment.
Brooke – It didn’t have to be like this. If you had asked for permission, I would have given it and, knowing me, proudly promoted your book on launch. It costs nothing to credit.
Penguin – You are a top tier publisher that is supposed to value and protect original content, and uphold the integrity of the publishing industry. But to me, the way you have handled this matter has shown a disregard for the very principles you claim to stand for.
I expected better from a publisher of your standing.
Do better. Because the authors who pour their time, skill, and originality into their work – the ones you claim to champion – deserve it.
– Nagi Maehashi
RecipeTin Eats
29 April 2025
.
PS Penguin and Brooke Bellamy – here is the policy for use of my recipes on my website which has been there since 2015.
FAQ
Brooke Bellamy, who wrote Bake With Brooki, runs a cookie shop in Brisbane, Australia, called Brooki Bakehouse. She is a social media influencer with almost 4 million followers across various social media platforms who grew her following extremely quickly in 3 short years.
The growth of her popularity on social media in turn lead to the popularity of her cookie shop.
Until 2022, she was a travel blogger for a decade, sharing stories of her travels around the world on a personal blog.
Penguin Random House Australia published her first book Bake With Brooki in October 2024.
92,849 copies of Bake With Brooki have been sold in Australia as at 23 April 2025 since the book was published in October 2024, according to Neilson BookScan.
Neilson BookScan is a data tracking service that reports actual sales of books to retailers and is used by publishers, industry professionals etc. in Australia.
This statistic includes sales of the second edition (in which the Caramel Slice recipe has been replaced) which I believe was only released a few weeks ago so would only account for a few thousand copies, at most. Penguin didn’t make an announcement when the new edition was released.
The Baklava and other recipes I flagged to Penguin have not been replaced in this second edition. I alerted them to these findings at a later date.
For the ones with extensive similarities, yes I did. I have not mentioned them by name at their request, and/or out of respect for their privacy. Whether they are considering action, have already taken steps or decided not to do anything, it is not my place to speak for them. I am deliberately handling my matter independently.
Plagiarism is using someone else’s work or ideas without proper credit and presenting them as your own. It happens everywhere – from high school essays to political speeches delivered to tens of thousands of people, to recipes in cookbooks.
It’s considered dishonest and unethical because it takes advantage of someone else’s effort and originality while misleading others into thinking the work is original.
In the book publishing world, plagiarism is unethical but plagiarism alone isn’t a crime and isn’t illegal.
If the plagiarised content is substantial enough and the original creator has copyright protection over it, then using it without permission or credit can be a copyright infringement, which is not allowed.
If there is a copyright infringement, the copyright owner can sue both the author and the publisher (if the publisher has made copies or authorised copies to be made). This can result in damages, injunctions, and public recalls of books.
Unfortunately, it is not a clear cut answer.
Copyright law protects creative expression, not facts or functional instructions. So while you can’t copyright the idea of “a caramel slice made without golden syrup in the filling” copyright can protect the way a recipe is written.
In practical terms, this means if someone copies enough of your words, they may be infringing your copyright. But if they just use the same ingredients and basic steps written in their own words, it’s usually not an infringement of copyright – even if it’s unethical because you have not been given credit.
This is why recipe plagiarism can feel so blatant and be unethical yet still be difficult to challenge legally.
That is the whole basis of this legal dispute – I have made allegations against Penguin that they have infringed my copyright.
Penguin have denied the allegations.
For legal reasons, unfortunately I can’t go into details here, as much as I want to lay it all out!
At this time, I have not commenced legal proceedings against either of them.
I can’t comment further on this topic, sorry.
The 3 recipes referenced in this post are not the only recipes I raised in correspondence with Penguin via our respective lawyers.
I don’t think it would be wise for me to comment further on this matter, sorry. I did warn you from the outset, I have to be careful what I do and do not say. It’s hard! Holding back does not come naturally to me, I like providing complete sets of information. 😭
Life of Dozer
I don’t want to put Dozer’s adorable furry face in a post dealing with such an unpleasant matter.
I’ll share extra photos of him in the next post to make up for it when I get back to sharing delicious recipes!
You are doing the right thing. I’m sure it doesn’t always feel that way. It’s like dealing with a bully, even if you can’t win you make them think twice about doing it the next time.
Personally I hope you win. I’m so tired of grifters getting the same air as grafters.
Dear Nagi I am so sorry you have had to go through such an unpleasant experience . I just want to give you big hug. I absolutely love your recipes and heavily promote them to young people just starting out on their cooking journey. You are my go to when Im looking to get inspired.
lots of love Pauline
I am completely sad that a person !
could stoop so low and thieve your recipes to make money 😡
Totally reprehensible and the word will be spread to friends to advise against buying the fake recipe book
So proud of you! I have followed you from the beginning and have always been so impressed with the trials and tribulations you go to so that the recipes always work! Deeply troubling that this hard work has been stolen. Sending you and Dozer lots of best wishes and keep up the fight!
Wow Nagi! Totally copied! Good on your for speaking up. I think when people know you are right, they prefer not to deal with it properly, as it shows admission of wrong doing and they would rather protect the reputation rather than admit fault and fix it. It really, really sucks and says a lot about them! I agree, the plagiarism is blatant – Brookie knows it – hence the no reply to your email. You did the right thing.
So sorry to hear that you have been cheated in this way. You are doing the right thing by making these people accountable for their actions. I love your recipes as they always turn out perfect! We all know how much how hard you work on getting the measurements and method perfect. Stay strong Nagi!
I have so much respect and admiration for you, Nagi. Behind you all the way. All power to your arm! 💪🏻
I worked in IP for 10 years (not a lawyer but a PA) what goes on is appalling. Not sure how Brooke can live with herself, stealing recipes … guess she is living it up in the Maldives. Shame on her
Nagi, I love your recipes, your ethics in supporting those in need and your generosity in so many things you are involved with but I’m saddened to see all these awful and just nasty comments about another person who none of these people know. Plagiarism is I agree very serious if this is what has occurred but also is cyber bullying. I understand you wanted to use your website to get your grievance out there but allowing people to make awful comments about another person is pretty poor in my view.
Your caramel slice is honestly life changing 🥰 I’m embarrassed to say how many I have made already this year!!
I’m sorry you’re having to deal with this. I hope you’re getting lots of hugs from Dozer ❤️
Nagi this sucks, I’m so sorry you’ve had to go through this.
Your integrity, strength and downright decency shine through. I hope this gets the media attention to shame those involved into a very public apology and prevents it happening to anyone else.
Your website and books have inspired so many of us and saved many a dinner time.
You are so loved, keep strong and a belly rub to your lovely furry boy from us. All the love to you xxx
That is so disappointing!! What can we do as a collective to help?
you are doing the right thing hang in there and fight for what is yours
Your caramel slice if honestly life changing 🥰 I’m embarrassed to say how many I have made already this year!!
I’m sorry you’re having to deal with this. I hope you’re getting lots of hugs from Dozer ❤️
Stay true to you Nagi. The voice telling you to make the post is the same voice that got you to where you are now. You can’t go wrong if you act with integrity and stick to your moral compass.
Who gives a flying fudge about tik tok and its impermanence in the REAL WORLD. What’s her face (won’t even dignify her with using her name) will have to come to terms with this and answer to it one way or another.
Power to you Nagi, you absolute legend!
How awful for you Nagi. There is no excuse for plagiarism and we your ardent followers know how much work and love you put into your recipes. Stay strong.
How awful for you Nagi. There is no excuse for plagiarism and we your ardent followers know how much work and love you put into your recipes. Stay strong.
You can do an online search and see that this would not be Penguin’s first suit related to plagiarism but I’m sure your lawyers know about that.
I wonder if you or your publisher know of other originating creators’ material contained in the offending book?
Sue her for every penny you can and break her. It is what she deserves.
I’m sorry this has happened to you.
Nagi, thank you for sharing & I am so very sorry you have been a victim of plagiarism & for this to be at the hands of what I have always thought as an iconic publisher. As for Ms Tik Tok Bellamy, your generosity in saying if she’d asked you gladly have shared speaks volumes.
I love your recipies and have both your books and swear by your Charlie sauce, which I always have in the fridge.
Love & support to you & Dozer
Sharon xx
I can’t believe what I just read! I love your recipes, your blog, and you and Dozer are amazing!
I’m hoping that you will set up a crowd funding page to help with your legal costs 👍
Hold your head up high and keep up the battle! xxoo